Community Engaged Scholarship, 2026-2027

Community Engaged Scholarship with thoughts from:
Farrah Jacquez, PhD
Professor & Assistant Director, UC Office of Research

Learning objectives 

  1. Describe pros and cons of community based participatory research
  2. Discuss how participatory research differs from traditional research methods
  3. Explore opportunities for publishing community engaged scholarship
Subscribe
Notify of

24 Comments

In order to appropriately include community partners in data synthesization, the key is to continue an ongoing conversation throughout the data analysis and collection process. I have found that this work can be done poorly in the event that the work is one sided, where academic partners collect and interpret data independently. For example, in the event the data collection process is extractive or if publishing is the only output as opposed to community dissemination and developing programming secondary to the data collection. 

In order for research to be collaborative with the research partner, there needs to be shared interpretation and ongoing conversations. In shared interpretation, members of the community board and partners are involved with the data analysis to best interpret within the lens of community needs. Additionally, it is important for community partners to assist with dissemination and help with dialogue surrounding the findings. The partners have the best sense of which channels are best to spread information to the community and in the most accessible manner. This is integral for application of the data so the community understands the findings and how they will be used. Finally, incorporating elements of the data collection into programs that directly benefit the community is integral to truly serve the needs of the community. 

A plan to ensure that this process is done well in the future includes planning how the data will be disseminated at the grant stage, sharing progress updates and results / next steps after the study, and agreeing on how the community partners can lead community facing materials. This is important to ensure that both sides are involved in the process and engagement to ensure the relationship is maintained even after the project has concluded. A narrative reviewed combined with diverse stakeholder perspectives was conducted to establish guidelines on community-academic partnerships created the Bidirectional Equity and Engagement (BEE) Framework, which emphasizes how to develop equitable partnerships and partnership outcomes. BEE adds a two way learning and dissemination process as part of an equitable partnership. 

Hi Nadia, I appreciate your response about the BEE framework. The point it makes about multilevel stakeholders is really interesting, because this relationship could often seem one-sided unless the academic partner feels some level of personal buying for the research that they’re doing or the desire to help the community. Successful instances of this I can think of are when subspecialty providers work to address health inequities or reasons that patients come into their office over and over again for the same conditions. Both parties have essential resources for each other, the academic side having expertise, and the community side having the subjects necessary to carry out the research, which ensures longevity and sustainability of this relationship.

I think this is unfortunately a very true fact and a struggle in advocacy work. There can often be a kind of placement of our values on the values of another, including another community. Sometimes saying, if saying “if I were in their shoes, I’d want this”, sounds more like “they should want this” and it isn’t always the case. Thankfully, I have had such a good example in my community partner. They have an empowerment group where folks in the pre-contemplative stage of IV drug use can talk about their struggles. While the group is not focused on rehabilitation or recovery, folks often find a way to rehab/recovery through the support of the group because of the touch points and trust building opportunities they have to people looking out for their best interest. One major win was that because law enforcement came to the empowerment group without judgement or ulterior motive, they were able to listen to the community, identify a change in the drug supply, and act on that change in a positive way so that a certain xylazine supplier was cut off at the root, something that wouldn’t have been done if the community was first villainized.

In the future, I think the most vital thing is to remember that advocacy done well starts with a well done community needs assessment. Folks in the pre-contemplative stage of using don’t need to be told to go to rehab, they aren’t there yet. They need to be listened to and understood in the space they’re in. If the big end goal is recovery for all and an end to HIV/AIDs, how can we help people live long enough to find that recovery? That is, at least, the name of the game when it comes to harm reduction. The goals simply have to be adjusted accordingly to support the real goals of the community.

This is an important area of discussion where stakeholders become co-creators in studies. One of the areas where I have seen this done well harkens back to the lab I worked in during my undergradue and master’s program at Michigan. Our group studied teaching and learning practices in college chemistry classrooms and one of the sites we partnered with was a small college among the Inupiaq Community in Utqiagvik, Alaska. I don’t remember the specifics of the study, but I know that it cenetered on investigating how tradtional knowledge systems and ways of knowing/thinking. I remember how intentional the two grad students and PI in the group were during the inklings of the project. I was with the group for 5 years total, and I think that the first paper was not published until year 3. The community in Alaska was in the driver’s seat. Folks there were co-leaders in the project and I beleive serves as a good example of participatory research done welll.

To do this sort of work well, you have to be intentional and earnest about forming a relationship long before the scholarly work begins, and likely be willing to continue that relationship after the work ends. You also need to consider the reality that the group may not be interested in participating in a study for various reasons, and that as academics we have to accept that reality with grace. It can be exhausting to be studied over and over again, especailly if study participants never see real change come from thier particiaption. Finding a deficit, a gap, a disparity, etc. only scratches the surface. I think that as researchers, we have to be willing to work, alongside community stakeholders, for change after the paper hits the press; it is insufficient to simply say “these desparities exist.” Arguably, the means to remidy a gap is more important work than identifying the gap itself…I don’t know, I think that at the end of the day, authentic partnership with a community means establishing a strong relationship well before study, being co-creators and leaders in shcolarly work, and continuing that relationship after publication in forms of advocacy, alliance, uplifter, etc. That is how we do this work well.

I definitely agree with your point about being intentional about the community relationship before the actual work on the study begins. I think this is why my research team during my M1 summer struggled to connect back with the community after the study ended. However, you are also right that not all communities will be interested in continuing the relationship. It’s very possible that the older adults we were working with would not have wanted to keep hearing from us. That’s another reason though to make sure it is set up right in the beginning, so that they have a fair opportunity to be involved or to choose not to. Also – the study with the community in Alaska sounds very interesting! I think that’s great that they were co-leaders in the project, since that is probably the ideal way for community research to be done.

My summer research after M1 focused heavily on community – we were investigating the efficacy of a program that provided free home-delivered healthy meals and weekly phone calls to socially isolated and food insecure older adults in the community. We wanted to see if there was a difference between depression, food security, and other health measures between older adults who received both the phone calls and the meals compared to older adults who received the meals alone. We collected both quantitative and qualitative data, but my PI was most interested in the qualitative. I felt that collecting the voices of the community members who participated in the project was one of the strongest and most impactful parts of the project, and helped to show their perspectives and priorities.

However, I think one failing of the project was that we did not find a way to share our results with the community. A barrier to this is that it is a large community and participants were spread out – one criteria for inclusion in the study was social isolation, so most participants had barriers to community resources that could otherwise have been used to share our findings. However, I still think we should have made more of an effort to communicate our results directly with the community, especially since our work was intended to benefit them. In the future, I think planning for how we will share our results with the community at the beginning of the project will be very helpful; that way we can incorporate it into the project and address barriers early on.

I’m glad your PI was focused on the qualitative data your group collected. I also like that you were able to reflect on what you would have done differently if you were to do this research again. Since your research involved people who are socially isolated, it’s hard to know if there would have been any difference if you would have attempted to communicate the results to them more.

It sounds like a cool project. Older adult isolation is a big problem that can have drastic negative consequences. I really like the idea of calling older adults weekly. It also sounds like it was challenging to share the results back with the group. I wonder if the PI considered sending the participants a nice printed copy of the study in the mail witha little one-page blurb with the big ideas?

As academics, we can only “know” something is true if it’s published in a very polished paper in Nature or Science… at least that’s what it often sounds like when we’re learning about research, research methods, statistics, and so on. However, when we are discussing observational research in communities where confounds can’t be completely controlled, it’s important to recognize that many members of the community know things about their own community that are not inherently observable to us as researchers. We often apply labels to behaviors we don’t fully understand, and then we report how strongly a certain behavior is correlated to a particular outcome. While certain qualitative research methods can be helpful in describing the inner workings of a community, it’s certainly insufficient to spend a year or two collecting “data” and believe that one can make a definitive statement about the community. 

I think my learning community made this realization during our service learning project during M1. We were certain that we were going to solve or at least positively impact the loneliness issue among the Hispanic women in the Price Hill community. We had been reliably informed that loneliness was a major issue for these women, and they needed our help to solve it. We collected very little information from women in the community before attempting to create a solution. As one may expect, our limited time in the community and poor understanding of what exactly makes this community tick did not lead to positive results for our project or for the women in Price Hill. We didn’t have the impact we had hoped, but our entire group gained a better perspective on the importance of getting the input of community members when trying to uncover and address perceived issues within a community.

You make a great point that obtaining input from the members at the core of the community is one of, it not the most important aspect of participatory research. I think it can be difficult to think about qualitative and community-based research at times, however there is real benefit from experiencing these communities first-hand by immersing ourselves in them and having real discussions with those who live in them every day. However, this can be challenging due to participant willingness or inability to obtain a sample large enough to reflect the entire community. Thanks for sharing your experience in your LC, and hopefully those lessons can be passed on to future classes and they can use that feedback to engage the community in a more meaningful way.

Thank you for sharing your experiences! I agree that a problem that many run into is running with an idea/problem that has been reported without reaffirming with community members that it is an issue that actually exist or is a problem that they even want addressed.

My current project is participatory research and I had never been involved in a project of its kind until this year. As a refresher, the project I am working on is a “photovoice” project, engaging community members to take photos in Bond Hill that remind them of climate change, and encouraging them to reflect on the photos and how they make them feel. One thing I have noticed about my project in specific is that the participants have repeatedly voiced frustration with decision makers coming into their community and discussing how they plan to make things better, but either true no change is made or the decision makers themselves don’t actually know what it’s like to live in Bond Hill or the concerns the members deal with. The PI of this project is a long-time resident of Bond Hill and I believe it adds to her credibility and trust when she approaches others in the community about what they’d like to change. She has been very careful about introducing bias as a resident of the community, and has had the sessions facilitated by members of Mantle Center who do not directly live in Bond Hill. I think this has opened the discussion to be authentic without persuasion, but also has let residents know that the PI can directly relate to the experiences discussed in the sessions, and she is truly interested in meaningful change within her own community.

One thing that is touched on often when discussing participatory research is how members of that community can respond when witnessing an outside source coming into the community for research purposes. It is extremely important to build a genuine connection with said community, because not only can it increase the willingness of members to participate in the research, but it can also signal to the members that the team is truly passionate in making change from the project. While writing up a paper is important to share findings, providing the members a space to reflect on the project or share their thoughts is an important aspect. In my current project, the PI met with community members after the sessions to review the video being made, with plans to share the video with policy and decision makers. The paper itself will highlight community member’s voices, as they are the center of the project and should be reflected as such. These are examples of ways to ensure a participatory research project is done well to truly involve members and make their voices heard.

I think it’s great that your PI has such close relation with the community you are working with and is emphasizing the community’s voice so well. I agree that it can be difficult coming into a community as an outsider with plans to do research and/or make changes, and that it is critical to create a strong, trusting relationship between the researcher(s) and the community prior to starting. Another thing you mentioned is how your PI is bringing the results back to the participants. The step of looping back to the community and participants and involving them in the sharing of data seems to be one that is often missed in my opinion. I think this step is so important because it shows the participants the value of the work they have done and the strength of their voices. It sounds like your PI is approaching this very thoughtfully and I imagine that her intention will help create a stronger and more long-lasting impact on that community. Thanks for sharing!

Being actively involved with EMS operations and interacting with the community at a ground level as well as being engaged in systems-based EMS research in my role as a medical student positioned me to be able to observe differences in the approach and the interplay that research had with the populations it impacted. One of the biggest gaps that I noticed was that research and quality improvement efforts can tend to focus on measurable outcomes while overlooking the perspectives of the communities they are intended to serve. For example, in rural healthcare, reducing emergency department visits may be viewed as a successful outcome, but that metric alone does not capture whether patients feel their needs are being met, whether they can access primary care, or whether they trust the healthcare system. My experiences working with EMS providers and exploring community paramedicine have reinforced that community members and frontline providers possess valuable insight into barriers that may not be apparent from the data alone. Research is most meaningful when it incorporates these perspectives and communicates findings back to the people whose experiences made the work possible, rather than limiting dissemination to academic posters and publications.

To tackle this problem, I feel that community involvement and proximity is paramount from the beginning of the research project, including the framing of the research question, identifying meaningful outcomes, and interpreting findings in the context of local needs. I would also prioritize sharing results in accessible formats, such as community meetings, plain-language summaries, and presentations to local EMS agencies and healthcare organizations. In rural and resource-limited settings, this feedback can help ensure that proposed interventions are practical, culturally responsive, and sustainable. As a future physician, I want to approach scholarship as a collaborative process rather than a one-way extraction of data. By closing the loop between research and the community, I hope to build trust, improve the relevance of clinical and systems-level interventions, and ensure that the people most affected by healthcare decisions have a voice in shaping them.

Ameya, I think that your experiences as a first responder have provided you with additional context on how the community is engaged in research objectives. I agree that some research projects are limited by the definition of their metrics of success. It can be easier to have a quantifiable statistic rather than a subjective opinion, especially when looking into a community-wide effort. I also feel like this can limit participation from the community, especially when the statistic doesn’t represent their understanding of a successful result. How exactly would you strike the balance between using a statistic and subjective community opinion? Where would you weigh opposing public sentiment and statistic?

Hello Ameya, thank you so much for sharing this perspective, your insight from a boots on the ground perspective is always so helpful! I love the emphasis on community involvement AND proximity. This is integral to understanding and gaining a pulse on the local needs of the community. I also appreciate your discussion about ensuring that the data is accessible to the community by ensuring the language is clear and understandable. While there are so many strategies to process this, I think being sensitive to this at the start of the project ideation is integral. It helps to ensure that the community members are at the root and center of this process. Overall, I think this emphasis on communication built in trust is important to solidify these partnerships! Thank you again!

Community engagement and involvement in research are often lacking and are critically necessary. To have community input on the focus of research and to have them included in the conclusions and next steps are both needed to most effectively uplift the communities surrounding research. One example that I have seen done well is through our Learning Community project with Caracole. Through our project development, we used the community to build the focus of our project and address key needs in the community. We found that Xylazine wounds were an increasingly present issue that needed to be addressed. And, at the end of the project, we provided Caracole with the structure to continue our Xylazine wound care kits and the information to keep supplying them as needed. By providing the final information and including them throughout the process, we not only geared the project towards their needs but also gave them access to appropriate next steps. On the other hand, I feel that I have seen the opposite done as well. Projects are created from the researcher’s end only, and the solutions or conclusions aren’t shared back to the community.

To ensure that the community voice is included in future projects, it must be the focus of the project. Their voices must guide the hand of the researchers and combine to address a need or question that is shared between them. This can be facilitated by making sure the researchers have taken the community perspective into account through active community engagement and presence. Also, the conclusions of the researchers must be shared with the community in need in an accessible way. Whether simplified or presented in a way to enact meaningful change, the community must be able to access the meaning of the results. Only through honest community involvement, engagement, and shared decision-making can research work with and build upon their community.

Brandon, I also talked about Caracole, how awesome is it that we got to have experiences that allow us to work with folks who do advocacy so well! I think about the challenge it was to keep those community members engaged in our own M1 project and I wonder how much of that is the surveys we created were for us and not them– our Pre surveys did great but then our post surveys had maybe 1 response? As I look to continue serving this population, I am also trying to get leaders in their community to have some investment in the work as well. I’ve always hated research for research’s sake, and you’re so right “through honest community involvement, engagement, and shared decision-making research can work with and build upon their community”

I think the most important factor in participatory research is involving the community early on in the process. The community should be directly influencing the design of the research study being implemented. One situation in which I think this could have been done better is my learning community project. We partnered with CAIN food pantry in developing, administering, and analyzing results of a needs assessment of their clients. Our group designed the needs assessment alongside CAIN leaders, developing questions we thought would address the greatest needs of the community they served. Although we did obtain a reasonable number of responses and were able to gather useful data on clients’ experiences with the pantry and our ideas for new programs, I do feel that the community voice was missing. We may have had even greater success if we involved some pantry clients in development of our questions, especially those surrounding new programming. Additionally, we did share our results and insights with CAIN leadership, but we did not return to the CAIN pantry itself and share these findings with their clients. I think a group session or discussion with any interested clients on our results would have been a good opportunity to gain even more feedback and ideas for CAIN’s leadership and ensure that community members felt heard and involved in the process.

Thinking through this raises ideas for my current project. I am working with Meals on Wheels to design a survey that will be used in their Social Connection department, with a focus on determining the efficacy of their programs in reducing social isolation and building connections. We will be conducting a pilot study of the survey tool with MOW clients and seeking their guidance and feedback in further design improvements of our tool. I think this is a great opportunity to hear client voices and allow them to directly influence the survey tool and its future implementation. I also plan to prioritize sharing our results and impressions back with those who are involved in our study.

This is great that you are taking the time to hear from client voices and allowing them into the process, which will better engage the community and better help to serve them. My research on safe sleep: we also want to engage the community to find ways to better serve them.

I have seen this done poorly through leaving racial and ethnic minorities out of clinical trials. This leaves this group out when it comes to varying drug responses, etc. I’ve also seen this done well when researchers intentionally engage the community and want a diverse dataset. For the future, advocating for more diversity in clinical trials/ scholarly activity can make a difference, even if small at first. Certain communities are not being engaged in scholarly activity, and we need to involve them in scholarly work. Increasing representation of researchers from racial and ethnic minority backgrounds will help with this too.

The organization I am partnered with, People Working Cooperatively, has the privilege of decades of experience under their belt communicating research findings with the community members they help. For example, they partner with undergraduate art students and pre-clinical medical students to create large displays that almost look like art installations, conveying various home safety topics. I had the privilege to visit their new headquarters earlier today and saw what seemed like a museum of interactive panels and signage conveying everything from lead safety to handicap accessible arm rails to neurodivergent sensory triggers and more. These pair with classes they offer for various populations of folks. They host a seven week course on preventing falls that incorporates these installations as methods of conveying information with trivia components and even lessons from physical therapist about ways they can personally reduce their injury risk.

It took a long time of trial and error for this organization to find a methodology of conveying information to the community that works well for them. But now that they have found this method, they are able to apply it for all of the new home improvement and healthcare causes that they decide to add to their services. For example, the neurodivergent sensory trigger home improvements are new, but they are able to use the same framework as what they use for asthma interventions and lead safety. It is far more common for activism or advocacy to stop right at the level of research findings being made to actual implementation the community, so I am glad to be working with an organization that seems to have cracked the code for this.

I think this is a very important discussion, especially when researchers are “outsiders” to the community. Even if the intentions are good, withholding results/outcomes can add to medical mistrust. I especially liked what Dr. Jacquez said about involving community members in the creation of the study, since the study questions will be more applicable and capture more accurate assessments. This is something I saw done very well in my undergraduate research group that was studying increased incidence of obesity in childhood Leukemia survivors. We hosted many focus groups with both parents and patients asking their impressions of weight/eating and asked for their input on our study design. These families had continued involvement through the design of the family based therapy plans. Finally, not only did the families learn about the results, they had the opportunity to enroll into the pilot treatment groups if desired. Involving the community is something I actually need to improve for my current project. I would like to have more in depth conversations with parents about my planned survey questions and feedback on the decoration kits. To do community based research well, there has to be a continued widespread culture change in research to see communities and individuals not as “data points”, but partners in the study. The sterile hierarchy of “researcher and subject” is holding us all back. This starts with building relationships with the communities even before any study begins, allowing team assessment of the validity of the investigation. And even more importantly, the relationship must continue and be maintained. Research should not be devoid of emotion- the voices and stories are the fuel for real progress.

24
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x